Cummins ISX vs Caterpillar C15: Which Engine Is Better?
The Cummins ISX and Caterpillar C15 are the two most iconic Class 8 diesel engines in North America. This guide compares them across every metric that matters — power, fuel economy, reliability, maintenance costs, and resale value — to help you make the right choice.
Quick Verdict
Choose the Cummins ISX If...
- Fuel economy is your top priority
- You need easy access to parts and service
- You run a fleet and need standardization
- You need EPA 2010+ emissions compliance
- Lower total cost of ownership matters most
Choose the Caterpillar C15 If...
- Maximum power and torque is your priority
- You want the legendary 6NZ reliability
- You're an owner-operator who values resale
- You prefer pre-emissions (pre-2004) simplicity
- You do heavy haul or off-highway work
Specifications Comparison
| Specification | Cummins ISX | Caterpillar C15 |
|---|---|---|
| Displacement | 15.0L (ISX15) / 11.9L (ISX12) | 15.2L (all variants) |
| Horsepower Range | 400-600 HP | 435-625 HP |
| Peak Torque | 1,450-2,050 lb-ft | 1,550-2,050 lb-ft |
| Fuel System | XPI Common Rail (post-2010) / HPI (pre-2010) | MEUI / HEUI Electronic Unit Injection |
| Aspiration | Variable Geometry Turbo (VGT) | Single Turbo / Twin Turbo (ACERT) |
| Weight (Dry) | 2,880-3,100 lbs | 3,050-3,250 lbs |
| Oil Capacity | 38-44 quarts | 40-46 quarts |
| Fuel Economy | 6.0-7.5 MPG | 5.5-7.0 MPG |
| B50 Life (Overhaul) | 750,000-1,000,000 miles | 800,000-1,000,000+ miles |
| Production Years | 1998-Present | 1993-2010 |
| Emissions | EPA 98 through EPA 2017+ | EPA 94 through EPA 2007 (ACERT) |
| Common Applications | Kenworth, Peterbilt, Freightliner, International | Kenworth, Peterbilt, Freightliner, Western Star |
Detailed Category Comparison
We break down the ISX vs C15 matchup across 6 critical categories that matter most to truck owners and fleet operators.
Power & Performance
Cummins ISX
The ISX15 delivers up to 600 HP and 2,050 lb-ft of torque. The XPI common rail fuel system provides precise fuel delivery and excellent throttle response. The ISX is known for smooth, linear power delivery that's easy to drive.
Caterpillar C15
The C15 produces up to 625 HP and 2,050 lb-ft of torque. The MEUI fuel system delivers aggressive, immediate power. Many drivers describe the C15 as having a more 'mechanical' feel with stronger low-end torque. The 6NZ variant is legendary for its power potential.
Our Verdict
The C15 has a slight edge in raw power and low-end torque, especially the pre-ACERT 6NZ. The ISX offers smoother, more refined power delivery. For heavy haul applications, the C15's torque advantage is noticeable.
Fuel Economy
Cummins ISX
The ISX consistently achieves 6.0-7.5 MPG in real-world conditions. The XPI common rail system optimizes fuel delivery at all RPM ranges. Advanced electronic controls and variable geometry turbo contribute to superior efficiency. At 120,000 miles per year, this translates to $3,000-6,000 in annual fuel savings over the C15.
Caterpillar C15
The C15 typically achieves 5.5-7.0 MPG. The MEUI fuel system is less efficient than common rail at partial loads. ACERT models improved fuel economy but added complexity. The C15's heavier weight also contributes to slightly higher fuel consumption.
Our Verdict
The ISX wins fuel economy decisively. Over a 5-year ownership period at 120,000 miles per year, the ISX can save $15,000-30,000 in fuel costs alone. This is the single biggest factor for fleet operators.
Reliability & Longevity
Cummins ISX
Pre-2010 ISX models (EGR-era) had well-documented issues with EGR coolers, turbo actuators, and injectors. Post-2010 ISX15 models with XPI fuel systems are significantly more reliable. Modern ISX15 engines routinely reach 1,000,000+ miles before overhaul.
Caterpillar C15
The pre-ACERT C15 (6NZ serial prefix, 1999-2003) is widely regarded as one of the most reliable diesel engines ever manufactured. Many 6NZ engines have exceeded 2,000,000 miles. ACERT models (2004-2010) introduced twin turbos and added complexity, reducing reliability somewhat.
Our Verdict
The pre-ACERT C15 6NZ is the reliability champion. For modern engines, the ISX15 (post-2010) and ACERT C15 are comparable. If you can find a clean 6NZ, it's hard to beat for longevity.
Maintenance Costs
Cummins ISX
Annual maintenance costs average $3,000-5,000. Parts are widely available from Cummins dealers, aftermarket suppliers, and online retailers. Cummins has the largest dealer network in North America with 3,500+ service locations. Injector sets cost $2,000-4,000.
Caterpillar C15
Annual maintenance costs average $3,500-6,000. Since Caterpillar exited the on-highway diesel market in 2010, parts availability has decreased and prices have increased. Fewer specialized mechanics are available. Injector sets cost $3,000-5,000. Pre-ACERT parts are becoming harder to source.
Our Verdict
The ISX wins on maintenance costs due to Cummins' extensive dealer network and parts availability. The gap is widening as C15 parts become scarcer. Budget an extra $1,000-2,000 per year for C15 maintenance.
Resale Value
Cummins ISX
ISX engines hold good resale value, especially the ISX15 (post-2010). A truck with a well-maintained ISX15 typically commands $5,000-10,000 more than comparable engines. The ISX is the most common Class 8 engine, so demand is steady but not exceptional.
Caterpillar C15
The C15, especially the 6NZ variant, commands premium resale values. A truck with a 6NZ C15 can sell for $10,000-25,000 more than the same truck with other engines. The 6NZ has a cult following among owner-operators, and values continue to rise as supply decreases.
Our Verdict
The C15 6NZ is the clear winner for resale value. It's one of the few diesel engines that has actually appreciated in value. However, ACERT C15 models don't command the same premium.
Weight & Packaging
Cummins ISX
The ISX15 weighs 2,880-3,100 lbs dry, making it lighter than the C15. The compact design fits well in most Class 8 chassis. The ISX12 variant at 11.9L is even lighter for weight-sensitive applications.
Caterpillar C15
The C15 weighs 3,050-3,250 lbs dry — approximately 150-200 lbs heavier than the ISX. The larger physical footprint can be tight in some chassis. No smaller displacement variant was offered.
Our Verdict
The ISX is lighter by 150-200 lbs, which translates directly to additional payload capacity. For weight-sensitive applications (tankers, heavy haul), this matters.
Final Scorecard
| Category | Cummins ISX | Caterpillar C15 | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Power & Performance | 9/10 | 9.5/10 | C15 |
| Fuel Economy | 9/10 | 7/10 | ISX |
| Reliability (Pre-ACERT/Pre-2010) | 7/10 | 10/10 | C15 |
| Reliability (Modern) | 9/10 | 8/10 | ISX |
| Maintenance Costs | 8/10 | 6/10 | ISX |
| Parts Availability | 10/10 | 6/10 | ISX |
| Resale Value | 7/10 | 10/10 | C15 |
| Weight | 8/10 | 7/10 | ISX |
| Emissions Compliance | 10/10 | 5/10 | ISX |
| Overall | 77/90 | 68.5/90 | ISX (Total Cost) / C15 (Legacy) |
The ISX wins on total cost of ownership and practicality. The C15 6NZ wins on raw performance, reliability legacy, and resale value. There's no wrong choice — it depends on your priorities.
Best Engine by Application
| Application | Recommended Engine | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Long-Haul Fleet | Cummins ISX15 | Better fuel economy at scale, easier parts/service, lower TCO |
| Owner-Operator (OTR) | Either / C15 6NZ | C15 6NZ for resale value; ISX15 for fuel savings |
| Heavy Haul (473,000+ lbs) | Caterpillar C15 | Superior low-end torque and pulling power |
| Regional/Short Haul | Cummins ISX12 | Lighter weight, good power, excellent fuel economy |
| Vocational (Dump, Mixer) | Caterpillar C15 | Robust design handles high-load, low-speed work |
| Glider Kit | C15 6NZ | Pre-emissions, simple, legendary reliability |
| Marine Conversion | Caterpillar C15 | Cat has stronger marine support and cooling options |
| Fleet Standardization | Cummins ISX15 | 3,500+ service locations, best parts network |
Frequently Asked Questions
Related Guides & Engine Pages
Cummins ISX Problems
Common issues and repair costs
ViewCaterpillar C15 Problems
Common issues and repair costs
ViewDiesel Engine Cost Guide
Complete pricing for all engines
ViewEngine Specs Database
Full specifications for 25+ engines
ViewShop Cummins ISX Engines
Browse remanufactured ISX models
ViewShop Caterpillar C15 Engines
Browse remanufactured C15 models
ViewSemi Truck Engines
All Class 8 engine options
ViewBreak-In Guide
How to break in your new engine
View